F & G Train Riders To Suffer A Lengthy Loss


Coney Island/Stillwell Ave. bound F train entering the Smith-9th Sts. station on the F & G. Resized photo courtesy of Eye On Transit

Yesterday’s edition of the Metro paper had a story sure to make riders on the F & G cringe. The MTA has announced that the Smith-9th Streets station will be closed up to 1 year as repairs made on the crumbling Culver Viaduct, which stretches over the Gowanus Canal. The repairs will also cause temporary platforms to be in use at the 4th Ave. station. No exact time frame has been given as to when the station will start being closed. Based on initial estimates, the initial guess is the closure will take up most of the year 2010.

Here are some comments about the project:

NYC Transit spokesperson Paul Fleuranges – “The bottom line is quite simple: The infrastructure work and system upgrades that comprise this project are necessary for the continued and future safe operation of the current F and G service.”

NYC Transit’s Connie Crawford – “We’ve talked to the community about that — they’re well aware. his is major, major work at that station.”

However Community Board 6 District Manager Craig Hammerman disagrees with Connie’s assessment which prompted him to say “We’ve jumped a step somewhere. We might have been blazed over. It would be an outrageous inconvenience.”

This is definitely a huge blow as that station is one of the most important stops the F makes in Brooklyn. I am sure local residents are not thrilled with this announcement. However I hope they understand that this is for everyone’s good & sometimes inconveniences are part of making things right.

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

MTA Looks To Go Trick Or Treating With The State

The MTA is looking to get $338 million dollars from the state next year. The funds would be obtained from dedicated taxes from the state’s Mass Transit Operating Assistance Account. If history is any indication, the MTA shouldn’t hold their breath waiting for that amount if any to be given to them. Though the money is owed to the MTA, history has shown that the state has regularly raided the fund for non MTA related projects.

The MTA expects the state to hand over $169 million dollars in 2009 from the account. They also want a recurring $50 million from the legislature beginning in 2008 along with an annual $600 million in recurring state aid starting in 2010. MTA CEO Elliot Sander also hopes to get money from congestion pricing if the plan gets approved.

My opinion, good luck seeing a dime of the money you truly deserve!

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

Subway Stabbing Victim Blames MTA

Yesterday afternoon I wrote an entry about a 51 year old woman who was stabbed at the 169th St. station on the F train. The victim we now know as Paula Jean Baptiste of Elmont, New York is thankful for 3 straphangers who helped her & the police lead to the arrest of 32 year old Hollis resident Matthew Corchado. However she is not extending her thanks to the MTA as she feels they are partially responsible for the attack taking place.

We now have details as to what exactly transpired during the attack. Mr. Corchado approached Paula at approximately 3:30 p.m. He told her that “You dropped something.”. She was suspicious of the claim but decided to take a peak anyway. When she saw nothing there, she said “No, I dropped nothing.” After she said this, he lunged at her & first stabbed her in the head. He followed that up by stabbing her in the shoulder. According to Paula, “He tried to kill me to get my bag.” She thought she would pass out but found it in her to fight him off. She went on to say; “I got strength and fought him. I screamed very hard and he let go.”

As she stood on the front steps of her home describing the attack, she offered praise to the two women who helped her after the altercation. She also wanted to thank the man who followed the suspect down the platform. However her next set of words were for the MTA & police who she feels fail to provide a sense of security inside the station. She feels more vigilance would have prevented the attack. She also offered this quote; “If there were police, then it would prevent it because he would be scared.”

As one would expect, this was not Mr. Corchado’s first run in with the law. His arrest for this attack was his third in the last 3 months. He was arrested 2 months ago for hitting a woman in the back of the head in Jamaica. 3 weeks after that, he was arrested for violating an order of protection set up for the woman who he hit in Jamaica. He went to a Queens Public Library where the victim was carrying a 4 inch pocket knife. He is currently being charged with attempted murder, attempted robbery, assault and criminal possession of a weapon for the attack on Paula Jean Baptiste.

The first question that jumps out at me is why was this guy walking our streets freely? Seriously if the signs weren’t there to tell you that he belongs behind bars, I don’t know if they will ever arrive!

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

New York Daily News Launces “Halt The Hike” Campaign

I was sitting around finishing up my dinner from Wednesday night. As I was doing this, I decided to flip through Wednesday’s edition of the New York Daily News again. When I flipped through it, I came across an article written by their transit beat reporter Pete Donohue. The article shares the paper’s feeling on the proposed fare hike that seems to be a certainty come the first quarter of 2008 & how it is launching a “Halt The Hike” campaign in hopes of changing the MTA’s mind. Here is the entire article:

The MTA is looking at a year-end budget surplus of more than $400 million.

Seven million daily subway and bus riders and hundreds of thousands of suburban rail commuters have been hit with two hefty fare hikes since 2003.

Gov. Spitzer has repeatedly said fare and toll increases should be a “last resort,” and a growing number of state legislators are dead set against squeezing riders for more money.

Yet the Metropolitan Transportation Authority wants to begin imposing a new series of fare and toll hikes in February.

Many straphangers and lawmakers want at least to delay any increases – and the Daily News agrees. That’s why The News today is launching a “Halt the Hike” campaign. Its goal: Slam the brakes on the rush to hike the fares.

Some other way must be found to raise the money – one that doesn’t pick the pockets of straphangers.

Transit experts and fiscal watchdogs agree the MTA is facing a fiscal crisis after years of inadequate funding by state and local governments.

A growing chorus in the state Legislature is urging MTA CEO Elliot Sander and the MTA board to delay fare and toll increases until April 15, said Assemblyman Richard Brodsky (D-Westchester). That would allow Albany to find more money for the MTA during state budget talks.

“April 15 gives us time to move government to the role it ought to be in – as the institution that keeps the fare affordable,” he said.

Brodsky said he’ll be at the MTA board meeting today to make the case.

The MTA’s preliminary 2008 budget envisions raising an additional $262 million next year through higher fares for subways, buses and commuter trains operated by the Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North. Drivers using MTA bridges and tunnels also would pay more.

“Surely Gov. Spitzer and state legislators can shift priorities to fill the MTA’s gap, which is about two-tenths of 1% of the state’s $121 billion budget,” said Gene Russianoff of the Straphangers Campaign. “After nearly a dozen years in the cold, it’s high time for the state to come up with a permanent and recurring [funding] source.”

With debt service and pension costs rising, the MTA says it’s facing a $1.4 billion deficit in 2009. And it only gets worse, the agency says.

“Despite $6 billion in deficits over the next four years, we’ve proposed a financial plan that invests in the future and actually increases service to meet growing demand,” said MTA spokesman Jeremy Soffin. “That requires both an enormous lift from Albany and cost-of-living increases from our customers.”

Soffin said delaying the increases would mean $100 million in lost revenue.

Transit advocates note the MTA expects to end this year with a $317 million surplus, and that doesn’t include recent data that show real estate tax revenues $60 million higher than previously forecast, fare and toll revenues up $49 million and health expenses down $25 million.

There are also other unused funds, including $350 million the MTA has set aside to prepurchase fuel and to pay pension liabilities this year, plus $50 million NYC Transit set aside for a stalled painting program.

“We should not raise fares until all options are exhausted, and that includes aid from the state,” said state Sen. John Sabini (D-Queens), the ranking Democrat on the Senate Transportation Committee. “It would be good if we got some leadership from the governor on this, and I think he’s prepared to give some.”

——–

I strongly agree with the position that the paper is taking. Unfortunately as right as they & many others are about the fare hike needing to be put on hold, I don’t see the MTA postponing it in any shape or form. The upcoming public hearings are nothing but a formality…..

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

MTA CEO Elliot Sander Says The Fare Hike Can Not Wait!

MTA CEO Elliot Sander
MTA Executive Director & Chief Executive Officer Elliot G. Sander; Photo courtesy of Mount Vernon Inquirer

These feelings were shared by Mr. Sander after today’s MTA board meeting. Mr. Sander said that any sort of delay in a fare hike would only cost the MTA more money in the end. He also went on to say: “The reality is the MTA is in need of great financial sums from Albany over the next two calendar years. For us to bank on this when the overall funding need is fares and tolls plus this aide, it…puts at risk the system we have worked so hard to build, to rebuild.”

Mr. Sander shared these feelings even after Westchester Democrat Assemblyman Richard Brodsky presented the board with a letter from 46 members of his chamber. The letter urged the MTA to postpone the fare hike vote until April 15, 2008 when lawmakers would take up the state budget. Mr. Brodsky also went on to say: “All we’re asking you to do is ask us to give you money. We’ll try. There are no guarantees…But working cooperatively, I believe that additional moneys can be found to save the fare.”

However Mr. Sander would have none of it as he said postponing the fare hike vote until April 15th, 2008 would cost the MTA $100 million dollars in revenue it desperately needs. MTA spokesman Jeremy Soffin reiterated that a December vote was needed due to fare hikes needing a few months to be prepared for their roll out after approval. The possible fare hikes are expected to be implemented between late February & April of next year.

You might enjoy reading these related entries: