LIRR Needs To Change Amtrak Agreement

I don’t need to remind Long Island Rail Road riders how much of a nightmare the Monday night PM rush commute was. Due to an emergency rail condition in one of the East River tunnels, the LIRR was forced to cancel 21 eastbound trains & suspend all westbound service into Penn Station.

The repairs which were done by Amtrak due to the agreement that they own & maintain Penn Station needs to change according to MTA Board Member Mitchell Pally. Alfonso A. Castillo of Newsday has more:

MTA and LIRR officials lashed out against Amtrak Thursday morning, calling it “unacceptable” that the agency conducted repairs in a Penn Station tunnel during the Passover rush Monday, severely disrupting Long Island Rail Road service.

At a Manhattan meeting of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority Board’s railroad committee, board member Mitchell Pally said the MTA should look to change its agreement with Amtrak, which owns and maintains Penn Station, so that the LIRR takes over the maintenance of the tracks it uses.

“They run the least amount of trains and have the least amount of people in the service, and run the program,” Pally said of Amtrak.

Click here for the complete report.

While some might say Mr. Pally is overreacting to the situation that occurred, I feel he makes an excellent point. While I understand the agreement that is in place, it does not make sense for Amtrak to have final says on things when they are the minority service provider from the facility.

They have a history of being extremely ineffective in terms of making timely decisions & getting things done. Unless the rail condition was of an extreme emergency variety, they had no business waiting until the PM rush to do the work. While 21 trains does not sound like a lot, that is a huge number for the LIRR considering it is the nation’s largest commuter railroad in terms of passenger loads.

I think this incident should lead to an overhaul of the agreement as it would benefit all parties involved & just make common sense. It will be interesting to see if Amtrak will be willing to change the status quo.

xoxo Transit Blogger

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

MTA Looking To Get $150M For 347 Madison

Once again, the MTA is looking to unload one of their real estate holdings to help boost the bottom line. Last month, reports started to surface that the agency was looking to unload the 347 Madison Ave property & the 2 adjoining ones at 341 & 345 respectively. Fast forward to yesterday where the New York Times note that the agency is looking to get up to $150M for the property. Charles V Bagli has more:

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority, which has consolidated departments and reduced its payroll under severe financial pressure, now plans to sell its headquarters and two adjoining buildings on Madison Avenue in a deal that it says could reap more than $150 million.

Transportation officials are hoping that a developer will pay top dollar for the properties, three 20-story office buildings that form the eastern blockfront between 44th and 45th Streets. A buyer could demolish the structures and erect a modern skyscraper, and could also buy unused development rights over Grand Central Terminal and build an even taller tower than might otherwise be allowed.

The three buildings might look bland and unappealing, but the allure is their location in a prime office district next to Grand Central, a workday entry point for executives coming from New York’s northern suburbs. The Yale Club is on the same square block.

While the buildings — 341, 345 and 347 Madison Avenue — may not be of architectural note, the authority’s headquarters and its hearing rooms have been the site of many a raucous demonstration, by employees, transit riders opposed to fare increases and cuts in service, or opponents of development on authority properties. It bought 347 Madison in 1979 for $11.9 million and 341 and 345 Madison in 1991 for $12.25 million and $23.75 million respectively.

The transportation authority considered selling the buildings before, in 1998 and in 2005, but decided against it each time. “I’d take a look,” the developer Douglas Durst said Tuesday, “for the third time.”

Click here for the complete report.

I have a problem with the agency’s plans to sell these properties. My issue is not about them getting rid of the properties themselves. They clearly need to continue their trend of consolidating space & saving money. However they have a history of rushing to make deals of this nature & in turn sell them severely below market value. Do I really need to get into the Atlantic Yards fiasco?

These properties are not exactly the most appealing inside however thefact they are prime pieces of real estate can not be denied. Even in the current market conditions, these are 3 valuable chess pieces in the game of Manhattan real estate as you know what they say, location, location, location!

I sincerely hope the MTA does not sell these properties at below market value as it will be a huge mistake. If they have to hold on to them for a bit longer to achieve greater value, then that is exactly what they should do. Hopefully they learned something from the Atlantic Yards fiasco unless cutting sweetheart deals for friends is on their agenda again which would be a crying shame.

xoxo Transit Blogger

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

Bus Diversions Due To Easter Parade

Earlier today, the MTA issued a brief press release to announce bus diversions due to the annual Easter Parade:

The annual Easter Parade in Manhattan will be held on Sunday, April 24, 2011 between 10 a.m. and 5 p.m. on Fifth Avenue between 49th and 57th Streets. For customers who what to show off their chic chapeaus, the closest subway station is at Fifth Avenue/53rd Street on the E line.

Due to street closures for the parade, the following bus routes will be affected: M2, M3, M4, M5, Q32, BxM3, BxM4, BxM6, BxM7, BxM7A, BxM9, BxM10 and BxM11.

MTA Bus, MTA New York City Transit buses and subways, as well as MTA Staten Island Railway, will operate on a regular Sunday schedule.

xoxo Transit Blogger

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

5 Train Service Suspended This Weekend

As you already knew thanks to the Service Diversions I list in advance, service on the 5 Train will be suspended this weekend. The MTA issued a press release with more information as to why:

MTA New York City Transit announced that 5 train service will be suspended this weekend from 11:30 p.m. Friday, April 22 to 5 a.m. Monday, April 25 due to work on three projects including the East 180th Street Signal Modernization.

Workers will be making preparations for the next phase of the East 180th Street signal project that begins on May 2. This new phase, which will run through the summer, will necessitate fewer 2 and 5 rush hour trains north of East 180th Street and the continuation of the suspension of afternoon northbound 5 express service.

This weekend, free shuttle buses will replace the 5 between Dyre Avenue and East 180th Street. Customers may take the 2 for service between East 180th Street and 149th Street-Grand Concourse and the 4 for service between 149th Street-Grand Concourse and Brooklyn Bridge. The 4 trains will run local in both directions between 125th Street and Brooklyn Bridge.

Brooklyn Bridge will be the last stop for the 4 train this weekend due to work at the Fulton Street Transit Center and track replacement south of Grand Central-42nd Street. There will be a special J subway shuttle available for service between Chambers Street-Brooklyn Bridge and Atlantic Avenue.

xoxo Transit Blogger

You might enjoy reading these related entries:

MTA Bus Good Friday Service Advisory

Here is the MTA Bus Company’s plans for bus service on Good Friday courtesy of a press release:

On Good Friday, April 22, MTA New York City Transit and MTA Bus Company buses will operate their regular weekday hours of service and travel paths with minor scheduling adjustments on some bus routes. MTA Bus routes Q6, Q25 and Q65 will not operate Limited-Stop service. Customers must use local buses instead.

MTA New York City Transit subways and the MTA Staten Island Railway are on a regular weekday schedule.

xoxo Transit Blogger

You might enjoy reading these related entries: